稿件退修时的注意事项

 

    (1) 对审稿意见要十分尊重，对每一条批评和建议，都要认真分 析。所有问题必须逐条回答（response to reviewer’s comments 1，2,3)。

    (2) 对修回稿中已修改的地方要具体标明第几页，第几行（page， lines) 0

    (3) 尽量满足职称论文发表意见中需要补充的实验。

    (4) 审稿人由于知识限制和某种成见，甚至学术观点不同，判断错 误并建议退稿常会发生。要极其慎重和认真地回答，有理有据地与审稿 人探讨。但要委婉地礼貌地表达你的观点（示例21-7)。

     示例21-7

     [不推荐] The reviewer’s comment was wrong

     [不推荐]The referee’s idea is bad，but mine is good [推荐]The reviewer’s comment is very interesting. However，we found that

     [推荐]It would be very interesting to see ???  However,—

     [推荐] The referee has an interesting notion, but the proposed idea is also good,particularly in light of this or that fact.

    (5) 不能做的也不要回避，说明合理理由。

　(6) 审稿人是论文的第一读者，如果他都没有读懂你说的某一方 面，作者得考虑自己的文章有什么问题让人家不懂，否则发表后如何面 对更多的读者？你需改得更清楚。

    (7) 如果你的论文又被拒绝是因为有一个审稿人对你的论文有很好 的评价，但另外一审稿人对你的论文评价很差。此时，如果你有理由认 为审稿人不合理对待你的论文。你可以写信给编辑要求更换审稿人。编 辑一般会将你的论文寄发给第2位审稿人。如果这位审稿人也评价很 差。那么，应该补充修改后改投其他SCI期刊。

　 (8) 给编辑回信，感谢给论文提出的修改意见，并指出按修改建议 已作的修改，未作修改的地方要说明理由（示例21-8和示例21-9)。

     示例21-8 SCI论文Resubmission样稿信-1

Dear Editor,

Thank you so much for giving us an opportunity to revise this paper. We have considered comments from reviewers carefully and have made revisions to address their concerns. I hope this revised version is acceptable for publication.

Sincerely ^

{your name here) Manuscript # ：Cell~07^555

Respo?ise to cornments of revievoers Revi erver 1 ：

General comments ；

     示例21-9 SCI论文Resubmission样稿信-2

Dear Dr. ，

Thank you for the opportujiity to revise our manuscript if 2007-5555

entitled，“ We are grateful for the detailed comments and sug

gestions provided by each of the reviewers ^and we believe that their input has greatly improved our manuscript. Because of the number of comments and Level oj detail provided by each of the reviewers，zue have included their comments verbatim in italics j follovued by our comments and revisions //? bold. Although this makes a rather lengthy cover letter，xve believe that it vuill provide you and your revierwers with the best explanation of the changes that we have made.

Sincerely,

{your name here)

Response to comments of reviewers